Title image

Rudy 2008?

I've not said much on this subject here, but those fretting about Giulliani being too liberal on key issues to support should click here. My argument is that in an election for President of the United States, it's more important that a candidate accepts and understands that a lot of the controversial social issues are reserved by the Constitution to the States, and as long as Giulliani understands that -- the indications are that he does -- and will appoint judges and justices who will so rule, his substantive views on what individual states should do with that freedom are less important.

Comments

Comment by Rock:
I will probably leave the presidential portion of my ballot blank in the November 2008 election, while otherwise voting a straight Republican ticket.

Here's why....

A co-habitation of Republican president and a Democrat Congress (I'll refer to this as "RP/DC" from now on) is bad for the country and bad for the Republican party. (Let me say up front that I don't believe that the Republicans are likely to regain control over either chamber of Congress, certainly not the US Senate where the Republicans are going to be defending 21 seats to the Democrats 12.)

The reason why this RR/DC is bad for the country is that it encourages the Democrats to be even more irresponsible demagogues than they normally are. The result is what I call a "punching bag presidency."

Example:

The Democrat Congress passes legislation increasing the national minimum wage. If the bill becomes law, jobs will be legislatively eliminated. But because the President is a Republican, any unemployment problem will be blamed on "the failed economic policy of the (insert name here) administation." If the bill is vetoed by the president, the Democrats demogogue the issue while Republicans in less than safe seats consider voting to override the president's veto.

This should sound familiar because this is how the RP/DC worked when the original Bush was president from Jan 1989 through Jan 1993. Power and responsibility were divided: The Republican president was responsible for the sagging economy. The Democrat Congress had the power to change tax law, regulations and laws concerning litigation that could impact the economy. But the public blamed the most visible person around: The Republican president (which meant the Republican party).

But it's even worse than I describe. The Bush tax cuts are due to expire in 2010. So, whoever gets elected president next year will be presiding over a large increase in taxation on capital formation while the Democrat Congress is clearly going to do nothing about it.

Have you noticed that a President's chances of winning reelection is much higher if he serves with a Congress in which at least one chamber is controlled by the Republicans?

The Republicans controlled the US Senate during Reagan's entire first term. Reagan was reelected in 1984.

The Republicans controlled both chambers of Congress in Bill Clinton's 3rd and 4th years in office. Clinton was reelected in 1996.

The Republicans controlled the US House during the first four years of George W. Bush's presidency. The GOP controlled the US Senate for the 3rd and 4th years of Bush's presidency. George W. Bush was reelected in 2004.

Gerarld Ford, Jimmy Carter and George Herbert Walker Bush were defeated in their reelection bids. What a coincidence that the Democrats controlled both chambers of Congress throughout all of their years in the White House.

To be an effective president you need a supporting cast.

Given that the Democrats aren't going to cough up Congress in 2008, I'm voting a straight GOP ticket, with the presidential portion left blank.
Timestamp: 5/11/2007 12:04:00 AM | Cite as: #1

Leave a comment:

Name:
Your Email address:

Keep my email address hidden
Your website / blog:
http://
Comments:

Spam protection:

If you're a human being rather than a spam robot, type "I am a human" in this box.

Recent entries
» Moving on up
» New Dream Theater
» Federalist Society Student Symposium
» The Guy Pratt website
» Rudy 2008?
» Christmas kitty pics
» Musical stuff: Walking on Air and Unicron's Theme
» OCILLA, ISPs and Contributory Infringement
» The Misguided Search for "the One Law - and the Ongoing Struggle to Articulate it Correctly"
» Voting representation for DC

Text-only version for PDAs and screen readers
Translate this site
The Federalist Society
GOP E-Corps
Get Firefox
Search the archives
Archives
May 2007
April 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004
May 2004
April 2004
March 2004
February 2004
January 2004
December 2003
November 2003
October 2003
May 2003
April 2003
March 2003
February 2003
January 2003
November 2002

Categories
Abortion
Blogs and blogging
Bureau of Motor Vehicles
Cat blogging
ConLaw
Default
Diane%20Sykes
Elections: 2006
Federalism
Feminism
Foreign policy: Iraq
Foreign policy: North Korea
Immigration
Internet
Kelo v. New London
Legal misc
Legal theory
Music
Newt Gingrich
Noise2signal
Politics
Russia
Scalia
Sciences
Supreme Court
The Nuclear Option

Blogroll
» Expressio Unius
» ACS blog
» Adam Yoshida
» AlaskaBlawg
» Alone in Public
» Andrew Sullivan
» Ann Althouse
» Appellate Law & Practice
» CenterFields
» Charging Rino
» Concurring Opinions
» Denise Howell
» Election Law Blog
» Emminent Domain
» Ex Post
» GOP Bloggers
» GrokLaw
» How Appealing
» Indiana Law Blog
» Instapundit
» Intellectual Conservative
» Is That Legal?
» Joel on Software
» Law & Letters
» Legal Miscellania
» Legal Theory Blog
» Little Miss Atilla
» Maryland Conservatarian
» May it Please the Court
» My Vast Right-wing Conspiracy
» National Center
» NinoMania
» Objective Justice
» Olympia Snowe 2008 blog
» Orin Kerr
» Paul Gowder
» PrawfsBlawg
» Purr Se
» ScienceBlog
» SCOTUS Briefs
» SCOTUSblog
» Siberian Light
» Sonic Frog Blog
» Starbucks Republican
» Sundries
» Talking Points Memo
» Tax Foundation Blog
» The Green Bag
» The Moderate Voice
» The Raw Story
» The Volokh Conspiracy
» Tim Roll Pickering
» Underneath their Robes
» Unlearned Hand
» Unused And Probably Unusable
» What Now?
» Yale FedSoc

Powered by Noise 2 Signal 2.0 Valid CSS!